Jeff Hoffman’s Phillies tenure is likely over as the team prioritizes cost-effective, flexible approach in 2025

Jeff Hoffman’s time with the Phillies appears to be coming to an end. After two stellar seasons in the bullpen, including a 2024 All-Star campaign, the 31-year-old right-hander is now a free agent, and all signs point to the Phillies moving forward without him.

Phillies Stack Up Pitching Depth

Over the past few days, the Phillies bolstered their pitching staff by trading for Jesús Luzardo and signing Joe Ross. Luzardo is expected to slot into the starting rotation, while Ross will begin the year in a swingman role, capable of filling in as a starter if needed.

• Phillies land Jesus Luzardo from the Marlins in exchange for two prospects >>
• Phillies sign righty Joe Ross to one-year deal >>

These moves, combined with the signing of reliever Jordan Romano earlier this offseason, leave little room—or financial flexibility—for Jeff Hoffman’s return.

Phillies plan to save Andrew Painter's innings for "July-ish," Dave Dombrowski said. Painter will throw but not pitch games in spring training, then build in minors at some point.

As for the bullpen, Dombrowski indicated they are likely done adding.

— Matt Gelb (@MattGelb) December 23, 2024

Read Between the Lines

When asked about Hoffman and Spencer Turnbull during a Monday press call, Phillies President of Baseball Operations Dave Dombrowski didn’t explicitly rule out a reunion but made the team’s stance clear. Under Dombrowski, the Phillies have been hesitant to hand out long-term contracts to bullpen arms.

While José Alvarado and Seranthony Domínguez received multiyear extensions in their arbitration years, both were relatively young (28 at the time) and came with mixed results.

Dombrowski acknowledged the inherent risk in long-term deals for relievers:

“If Mariano Rivera was there, I’d be happy to go four years,” Dombrowski joked. “But there’s just a lot of inconsistencies in relievers in general.”

This philosophy helps explain why the Phillies targeted Romano with a one-year, $8.5 million deal despite his injury history. If Romano struggles, the team can move on next offseason without a significant financial commitment.

“Well, of course, they’re not with us now, and I cannot for baseball rules comment on free-agent players,” Dombrowski said. “But I would just say, right now, we’re happy where we are with our bullpen.”

Translation: Jeff Hoffman and Spencer Turnbull are unlikely to return, with Ross effectively replacing Turnbull’s role. Hoffman, meanwhile, is seeking a multiyear deal that doesn’t align with the Phillies’ recent approach to building their bullpen.

Hoffman has been nothing short of excellent during his time in Philadelphia, posting a 2.28 ERA over 122 appearances across two seasons. He emerged as a reliable late-inning option and earned his first All-Star nod in 2024.

However, Jeff Hoffman is now 31 and reportedly seeking a multiyear deal in the range of three years and $39 million. Given the Phillies’ current luxury tax payroll of around $304.42 million—well above the $301 million threshold taxed at 110%—adding Hoffman without subtracting elsewhere would effectively cost the team close to $30 million in 2025 alone.

Dombrowski’s moves suggest the Phillies are content with their bullpen depth heading into spring training. Romano joins a group that already includes Alvarado, Domínguez, Matt Strahm, and Gregory Soto, among others.

While Jeff Hoffman is one of the top relievers still available, the Phillies appear unwilling to deviate from their cautious approach to bullpen construction.

Jeff Hoffman has been a valuable piece for the Phillies, but the combination of his market demands, the team’s luxury tax situation, and their aversion to long-term deals for relievers make a reunion unlikely.

For Phillies fans, Jeff Hoffman’s success in the bullpen won’t be forgotten, but the team seems ready to move forward with a more cost-effective and flexible approach. As for Hoffman, he’ll likely land a lucrative deal elsewhere—proof of how much his stock has risen in Philadelphia.

Join The Chase