Bryce Harper almost signed with the Giants and Bruce Bochy leaving is the reason he didn’t

Seven years later and we are just now finding out how close Philadelphia came to missing out on Bryce Harper.

Ahead of the World Baseball Classic, Bryce Harper went on the Pat McAfee Show and revealed that his 2019 free agency decision came down to two teams: the Philadelphia Phillies and the San Francisco Giants.

The thing that pushed him toward Philadelphia? Bruce Bochy parting ways with San Francisco. Bochy leaving removed a key piece of what made the Giants attractive to Harper, and the rest is history.

Bryce Harper was down to the Phillies and Giants in free agency

"It came down to Phillies, Giants. … It was close."

Bryce Harper revealed he nearly picked the Giants in free agency years ago 👀

(via @PatMcAfeeShow) pic.twitter.com/IvdIYPlrhL

— SportsCenter (@SportsCenter) March 2, 2026

Think about that for a second.

One manager’s retirement decision changed the entire trajectory of the Philadelphia Phillies franchise.

February 28th marked seven years since Harper signed his 13-year, $330 million deal with Philadelphia, and the anniversary feels even more significant now that we know how close it was to going the other way.

Seven years ago: The Phillies signed Bryce Harper and it has been worth every penny

At the time, plenty of people questioned the contract. $330 million for a 26-year-old outfielder was an unprecedented number. The Phillies were not a playoff team. The deal ran through his age 38 season. There were real concerns about whether Philadelphia was paying for the peak years or handcuffing the roster through the decline.

Those concerns are long gone.

In 858 regular season games as a Phillie, Harper is hitting .281 with 879 hits, 179 home runs, 530 RBIs, and 544 runs scored. He won a National League MVP. He came back from Tommy John surgery, shifted to designated hitter, and found a way to be just as dangerous at the plate. He ended a decade-long postseason drought and turned this organization back into one the national baseball world takes seriously every October.

The postseason numbers are what really tell the story. In 38 playoff games as a Phillie, Harper is hitting .311 with 41 hits, 12 home runs, 24 RBIs, and 30 runs scored. The 2022 NLCS alone made him a legend in this city for life. He is one of the best postseason hitters of his generation and he has done it wearing red pinstripes.

The only thing missing is a World Series ring. That is the one piece that would make this contract complete in the way Philadelphia always imagined it could be. The window is still open and Harper is still producing on a roster built to compete.

Seven years in, the honest verdict on the Bryce Harper signing is simple. It saved Philadelphia baseball. And somewhere in San Francisco there is a very different version of this story that almost happened, all because Bruce Bochy decided to retire.

Join The Chase