After a Cristopher Sanchez disaster-class in Kansas City, Phillies drop two straight to the Royals

Cristopher Sanchez, who has been the best left-handed pitcher in the National League all season and is supposedly auditioning for the NL starting assignment at the All-Star Game at Citizens Bank Park next week, got absolutely destroyed by the Kansas City Royals on Monday afternoon in a 15-1 loss at Kauffman Stadium that was over before the first inning was finished.

Sanchez gave up nine earned runs in 3 1/3 innings with a career-high three home runs allowed, all on his changeup, while the Royals piled up 12 hits against a pitcher whose ERA entered the game at 2.00 and left it at 2.62 because one afternoon in Kansas City against one of the worst teams in the American League inflicted more damage on his season numbers than the previous three months combined.

Say It Aint So, Cristopher Sanchez

Cristopher Sanchez's final line vs. the Royals

3.1 IP, 12 H, 9 ER (career-high), 1 BB, 1 SO, 3 HR (career high) pic.twitter.com/VovF8ooGpq

— Talkin' Baseball (@TalkinBaseball_) July 6, 2026

Cristopher Sanchez described the outing as “crap” after the game, which is the most honest and accurate self-assessment a pitcher can give after getting chased before the fourth inning against a team that entered the day 35 games under .500 and had no business doing that kind of damage to the best left-hander in the National League.

His sinking fastball averaged 94.8 mph, down a tick from its 95.2 season average, and his signature changeup produced six swings and misses but was up in the zone often enough that the Royals crushed it for three homers when they got a pitch to hit because a changeup that lives in the upper part of the zone against major league hitters is a batting practice fastball with a different grip.

The 12 hits allowed matched a season and career high and the 3 1/3 innings were Cristopher Sanchez’s shortest outing in over a year since exiting after two innings against the Mets in April 2025 with forearm soreness, except this time there was no injury to blame and no extenuating circumstances beyond a pitcher who simply didn’t have it on a day when the Phillies needed him to bounce back after Sunday’s loss and instead got the worst start of his entire season against the softest opponent on the schedule.

Turner’s Error in the First Inning Changed the Entire Game

The Phillies actually struck first when Turner opened the game with a double off the center-field wall and scored on a Bohm double to take a 1-0 lead that looked like the start of a comfortable afternoon against a bad Kansas City team.

Then the bottom of the first inning happened and everything changed because Turner threw away a potential inning-ending double-play ball that would have gotten Sanchez out of the inning with minimal damage and instead opened the door for the Royals to score six first-inning runs that turned a 1-0 Phillies lead into a 6-1 deficit before Sanchez had recorded more than three outs.

Trea Turner owes Cristopher Sanchez an apology here

Trea Turner's throwing error that opened the door for the Royals to score six first-inning runs off Cristopher Sánchez: pic.twitter.com/LMkT0AVZ2c

— NBC Sports Philadelphia (@NBCSPhilly) July 6, 2026

Turner was charged with his 12th error of the season on the throw, which makes him the lowest-ranked shortstop in the majors at minus-8 defensive runs saved according to FanGraphs, and while a double play can’t be assumed in the official scoring rules, which meant all the runs against Cristopher Sanchez in that inning were ruled earned.

Everyone who watched the play knows that the inning is over with two outs and nobody on if Turner makes the routine throw that every shortstop in the major leagues is expected to make. Turner said he rushed the throw, which is the kind of explanation that sounds reasonable for a single error but becomes a pattern when you’re a shortstop with 12 errors through 90-something games and a defensive reputation that has been deteriorating since the day you signed an 11-year contract.

Turner’s Defense at Shortstop Is Real Bad These Days

You hear a lot about the bullpen, the back end of the starting rotation, and the need for a right-handed hitting outfielder as the Phillies’ biggest flaws heading into the trade deadline, and all of those concerns are legitimate and need to be addressed.

Trea Turner’s defense at shortstop is a significant deficiency that the club cannot hide from anymore because the errors keep piling up and the range keeps declining and the routine plays that every shortstop in the majors is expected to make keep turning into adventures that cost the pitching staff runs that shouldn’t be on the scoreboard.

Turner made 40 errors in his first two seasons with the Phillies before the defense improved last year when he made just eight, which suggested the problems were behind him and the move to Philadelphia had just required an adjustment period.

Now the defense is an issue again with 12 errors already this season and a minus-8 DRS that ranks dead last among qualified shortstops in the majors, and the question of whether Turner can continue to play the position at an acceptable level for a team with championship aspirations is no longer something that can be waved away by pointing to his bat or his stolen bases or his hot streak over the last two weeks.

Turner is in the fourth year of an 11-year contract that runs through 2033, which means the Phillies are committed to him for another seven years regardless of where he plays defensively, and Dombrowski has said in the past that the club has not considered moving Turner to the outfield.

The team might have to start thinking about it before long because the defensive metrics are getting worse, the errors are accumulating at a rate that directly impacts the pitching staff, and Monday’s botched double play turning a routine first inning into a six-run catastrophe against the worst team on the schedule is the kind of moment that should force the front office to have an honest conversation about whether the best version of the Phillies’ roster has Trea Turner at shortstop or somewhere else on the diamond.

The All-Star Audition Is Tarnished but Sanchez Is Probably Still Starting

Sanchez’s ERA jumping from 2.00 to 2.62 in the span of one outing against the Royals has taken some of the shine off his All-Star candidacy, and the pattern of his recent road struggles is concerning because he’s allowed 18 runs in 14 innings across his last three road starts after spending the first three months of the season looking untouchable regardless of the venue.

The road version of Sanchez over the last few weeks has been a significantly different pitcher than the one who posted the fifth-longest scoreless streak since 1893 earlier in the season, and whether Monday’s blowup was an aberration caused by Turner’s error opening the floodgates or a sign that opposing lineups are starting to figure out the changeup is something the Phillies need to monitor closely heading into the second half.

Cristopher Sanchez will make his final start before the break on Saturday in Detroit and he’s probably still in the driver’s seat to start the All-Star Game next Tuesday night at Citizens Bank Park because the body of work across the full season is too strong for one terrible outing to knock him out of contention.

The luster of the run has been stripped away over the last few starts and Sanchez showing up at the All-Star Game with a 2.62 ERA instead of a 2.00 ERA because the Royals hung nine runs on him is not the way anyone in the organization envisioned the co-ace entering the Midsummer Classic at his home ballpark.

The Phillies Got Hammered 15-1 and the Lineup Wasted Every Opportunity

Beyond the Cristopher Sanchez disaster and the Turner error, the Phillies’ offense went 1-for-9 with runners in scoring position and left 15 men on base including the bases loaded twice early in the game when they had a chance to build on the 1-0 lead and put pressure on Kansas City’s pitching staff before the Royals’ six-run first inning changed the entire complexion of the afternoon.

Kansas City lefty Noah Cameron pitched five innings against the Phillies despite walking five batters because the Phillies couldn’t capitalize on the free baserunners and kept stranding guys in scoring position when a big hit would have changed the game.

A pitcher who walks five in five innings should be getting roughed up by a lineup with Schwarber, Harper, Marsh, Turner, and Bohm in it, but Cameron used a six-pitch mix and a fastball that averaged just 92.7 mph to keep the Phillies off balance because apparently the Phillies’ bats decided to take the day off along with the pitching staff and the defense.

Two Straight Blowout Losses to the Royals Is Unacceptable

Getting hammered 15-1 by Kansas City for the second consecutive day on a road trip where the Phillies were supposed to be feasting on bad teams before the All-Star break is the kind of result that puts a dent in the momentum the team had been building since the Washington series and the Mets trip.

The Phillies are 50-40 and still 10 over .500, which is fine in the big picture, but dropping two straight to one of the worst teams in the American League by a combined score that nobody wants to calculate heading into the break is not the way a team with five All-Stars and championship aspirations should be performing against inferior competition.

Cincinnati is next for three games starting Tuesday before Detroit for three to close out the pre-break schedule, and the Phillies need to right the ship immediately because going into the All-Star Game with four or five losses against the Royals, Reds, and Tigers after being expected to dominate the soft part of the schedule would waste the opportunity to enter the second half at 15 over .500 and within striking distance of Atlanta.

Cristopher Sanchez gets one more start Saturday in Detroit to shake off the worst outing of his season before the All-Star Game. Turner needs to figure out his defense at shortstop before it costs the Phillies another game they should win comfortably.

The lineup needs to stop going 1-for-9 with runners in scoring position and leaving 15 men on base against a team that is 35 games under .500 because that kind of situational hitting is what gets you bounced in the first round of the playoffs when the pitching on the other side isn’t a 92 mph lefty from Kansas City but a front-line starter who doesn’t walk five batters and get away with it.

Join The Chase