Aaron Nola coughs up three solo home runs in Phillies 4-1 loss to the Mets

The Phillies came back from the All-Star break on Thursday night and immediately reminded everyone that the problems that existed before the Midsummer Classic didn’t magically disappear during the four-day vacation.

Canadian wildfire smoke is rolling into Philly on top of a heat wave that’s already making the city unlivable >>

Aaron Nola gave up three solo home runs in a 4-1 loss to the Mets at Citizens Bank Park while Canadian wildfire smoke turned the air into a murky gray haze that made Center City invisible from the ballpark.

MLB to Phillies Fans: Damn the lungs, play ball.

Scenes in Philadelphia as the wildfire smoke rolls in during the Mets-Phillies game 😮 pic.twitter.com/ahil4fh2ST

— ESPN (@espn) July 16, 2026

Major League Baseball seriously considering postponing the game before deciding that the only contest on the entire league schedule combined with ESPN being in the house for a national broadcast was more important than the respiratory health of the 40,109 fans who showed up to breathe particulate matter and watch Aaron Nola continue his season-long struggle with the home run ball.

That was essentially the league’s position on Thursday evening when they moved the start time up an hour to 6:10 PM as a concession to the air quality while still requiring everyone in the building to spend three-plus hours inhaling Canadian wildfire smoke because television contracts don’t care about air quality indexes and ESPN doesn’t reschedule national broadcasts because the sky looks like the opening scene of a post-apocalyptic movie.

The air was hazy at first pitch and got progressively worse as the game went on with umpires checking in with players throughout the night to see if they were okay, which is the kind of mid-game wellness check that tells you the conditions were bad enough that the people on the field were concerned about their ability to function physically while playing a professional baseball game.

By mid-game Center City, which is usually visible from Citizens Bank Park as one of the most recognizable skylines in the country, had completely disappeared behind a low-hanging cloud of wildfire smoke that made the ballpark feel like it was sitting inside a fog machine at a haunted house rather than a major league stadium in the middle of July.

Nola’s “Quality Start” Was Anything But Quality

By definition, Aaron Nola turned in a quality start on Thursday because he pitched six-plus innings and allowed three or fewer earned runs, which is what the stat line says when you write it down on paper without any context about how the three runs scored.

All three came on solo home runs, one on a slider, one on a sinker, and one on a four-seam fastball, which means Nola gave up homers on three different pitches to three different hitters because the home run problem that has followed him for four consecutive seasons isn’t specific to one pitch or one count or one type of mistake but a pervasive inability to execute in the zone without leaving something over the plate that major league hitters can drive out of the ballpark.

Nola has now given up multiple home runs in five of his last six starts, which is a stretch of homer-prone pitching that would get most pitchers pulled from the rotation entirely but continues for Nola because the Phillies don’t have a better option behind him and the front office hasn’t acquired a replacement yet despite the trade deadline being 17 days away.

The 6.04 ERA through 18 starts, the league-leading home run totals allowed over the last four seasons, and the inability to put hitters away in two-strike counts that has defined his entire 2026 campaign were all on display Thursday night in front of a national television audience that got to watch the Phillies’ $172 million fourth starter give up back-to-back homers in the seventh to Brett Baty and Francisco Alvarez after Mattingly decided to send him back out for the seventh inning at 90 pitches instead of going to the bullpen the way he did last Friday in Detroit when he hooked Nola after five and the bullpen imploded.

Mattingly was damned either way on the seventh-inning decision because pulling Nola last week and watching the bullpen blow up was the wrong call according to Wheeler and the pitching staff, and leaving Nola in this week and watching him give up back-to-back homers was apparently also the wrong call because the result was the same regardless of which door the manager chose.

The problem isn’t Mattingly’s decision-making in the seventh inning but the fact that the decision exists at all because a $172 million starter shouldn’t be putting his manager in a position where the choice is between pulling him and hoping the bullpen holds or leaving him in and hoping he doesn’t give up another homer, and Nola has been creating that impossible choice for Mattingly every five days since the season started.

Nola did pitch out of a no-out, bases-loaded jam in the fifth inning, which was a legitimately impressive piece of pitching that showed the veteran can still compete in high-pressure situations when the adrenaline is flowing and the stakes of the moment demand his best stuff. Then two innings later he gave up back-to-back homers to Baty and Alvarez because the focus and the execution that produced the escape in the fifth couldn’t sustain itself long enough to get through seven innings without the home run ball rearing its head again.

Phillies Offense Was Dead on Arrival

Mets starter Christian Scott held the Phillies to three hits over 5 2/3 scoreless innings with zero walks and seven strikeouts because the Phillies’ offense came back from the All-Star break looking like it had spent the four days off forgetting how to hit rather than resting up for the second half.

The Phillies rank dead last in the majors with a .302 on-base percentage, which is a number that should terrify everyone in the organization because you cannot sustain a playoff run with the lowest OBP in baseball regardless of how good your pitching staff is.

WATCH: Phillies fan caves under pressure, costs Kyle Schwarber his 33rd home run of the season >>

The Phillies had runners on the corners in a 1-0 game in the sixth inning and Marsh struck out to end the threat, which was the kind of missed opportunity that defines games where the offense can’t produce against quality pitching and the margin between winning and losing comes down to one at-bat with runners in scoring position that doesn’t go your way.

Turner hit a solo homer in the eighth to make it 3-1 but it was too little too late because the Phillies had managed just three hits through the first seven innings and the offense never built any sustained pressure on the Mets’ pitching staff outside of the one inning where they had runners on the corners and couldn’t cash in.

Marsh’s July Slump Is Becoming a Problem

Marsh was leading the National League with a .338 batting average on June 7 and has been hitting .167 in July, which is the kind of monthly collapse that turns an All-Star first half into a concerning second-half trajectory if the slump extends into August when the games start getting tighter and the Phillies need every bat in the lineup producing consistently.

He’s down to .297 for the season after the July decline and while .297 is still a strong number for a full season, the gap between .338 Marsh and .167 Marsh is the difference between the Phillies having the best outfielder in the National League and the Phillies having a left fielder who is killing rallies with strikeouts in big spots the way he did in the sixth inning on Thursday with runners on the corners.

Marsh did line out hard to left in his final at-bat, which suggests the contact quality isn’t as bad as the .167 July average indicates and the hits might start falling again if he keeps putting the ball in play with authority rather than expanding the zone and chasing pitches he was laying off during the hot streak. But the All-Star break didn’t reset the slump and the Phillies need the first-half version of Marsh back immediately because the second-half schedule is too demanding to carry a left fielder who is hitting .167 for the month in a lineup that already ranks last in baseball in on-base percentage.

The Wildfires Made Everything Worse and More Smoke Is Coming

The Canadian wildfire smoke hanging over Citizens Bank Park on Thursday turned an already disappointing loss into a genuinely miserable experience for the fans who showed up and spent three hours breathing air that health officials had been warning people to avoid all week.

The scene at the ballpark with the hazy sky, the invisible skyline, and the umpires checking on players between innings felt more like a disaster preparedness drill than a professional baseball game, and the fact that MLB pushed the game through despite seriously considering a postponement tells you the league prioritizes the broadcast schedule over player and fan safety when the two interests come into conflict.

More smoke is in the forecast for Friday but the Phillies and Mets are off before the series resumes Saturday when rain is expected, which means the weather might actually solve the air quality problem by washing the smoke out of the atmosphere and giving everyone in the region a chance to breathe something other than Canadian wildfire particulate for the first time in days.

Welcome to the Second Half

The Phillies lost 4-1 to the Mets in wildfire smoke with Nola giving up three homers and the offense producing four hits because the second half of the 2026 season apparently started the same way the first half did back in April with Nola struggling, the offense disappearing, and the conditions surrounding the game being so bad that nobody wanted to be at the ballpark even though 40,109 people showed up anyway because Phillies fans don’t let Canadian wildfires, smoky air, or a dead-last OBP keep them from watching baseball.

The Phillies are 53-44 and 2.5 games back in the NL East with the Dodgers coming to town next week for a three-game series that is going to be the most significant homestand of the second half.

Nola gave the Phillies exactly what Nola has been giving them all season, which is six innings of survivable pitching punctuated by home runs that turn manageable games into losses, and the offense gave the Phillies exactly nothing against a Mets starter who isn’t going to make anyone forget about Jacob deGrom but was good enough to shut down a lineup that ranks last in baseball in getting on base.

The trade deadline is 17 days away and Dombrowski still needs a starter, a lefty reliever, and a right-handed bat. Thursday’s loss was a reminder that the holes on this roster haven’t been filled yet and the second half isn’t going to be kind to a team that enters it with the lowest OBP in baseball and a fourth starter who gives up three homers every time he takes the mound.

The smoke will clear eventually. Whether Nola’s home run problem will clear is a different question entirely, and one the Phillies can’t afford to keep asking for much longer.

Join The Chase