Trea Turner had a WILD NIGHT as the Phillies beat the Dodgers 10-7 in South Philly
Trea Turner experienced the full spectrum of what it means to be a Philadelphia athlete on Monday night at Citizens Bank Park by getting booed vociferously for his defense, cheered euphorically for his offense.
At the very least, it all ended with everyone laughing at the absurdity of Trea Turner’s own performance in the ninth inning when another ball got through him and his teammates started talking shit from the dugout. That’s fun in July, but I don’t think we’d be having the same party in October, ya know?
Still, at a certain point in a game where Trea Turner has driven in five runs and made three errors, the only human response left is to laugh at the fact that you’re simultaneously the best and worst player on the field at the same time.
Trea Turner hit a two-run homer and a three-run shot that just snuck inside the left-field foul pole for the 200th homer of his career, drove in five runs, ripped the 300th double of his career in the first inning, and was the single biggest reason the Phillies beat the Dodgers 10-7 in a wild game that the offense had to win twice because the defense kept giving runs back to Los Angeles through Turner’s glove at shortstop.
He also committed his 15th error of the season in the first inning, his third in the last four games, and misplayed three other balls that were generously scored as base hits rather than errors, which means Turner was directly responsible for at least four plays that put Dodgers runners on base or allowed runs to score on a night where the Phillies needed every one of his five RBI to survive.
Trea Turner RING IT
Trea Turner RING IT x2
There’s a ton to pick home last night but the worst error came in the sixth inning when Trea Turner failed to make a play on a generously scored infield hit by Andy Pages with two outs that allowed a run to score and cut the Phillies’ lead to 4-3.
The boos from 43,000 fans at Citizens Bank Park were loud and immediate because the crowd had watched Turner botch plays all night and the frustration of watching a $300 million shortstop turn routine grounders into adventures was boiling over in a game against the best team in the National League where every run mattered and the defense kept giving them away.
Then the very next half-inning Trea Turner stepped to the plate and crushed that three-run homer above just inside the left-field foul pole to cap a four-run inning and push the lead to 8-3, and the same fans who were booing him three minutes earlier were on their feet screaming because the man who can’t field a ground ball just hit his 200th career homer to blow the game open against the Dodgers at Citizens Bank Park on a Monday night in July.
The boos turned to cheers in the span of one at-bat because that’s how it works in Philadelphia when a player who is driving you insane with one part of his game redeems himself with another part in the same inning.
Trea Turner Error
Trea Turner Error x2
Not Featured Trea Turner Error x3
The Defense Is a Genuine Problem That Isn’t Going Away
The laughter in the ninth inning when another ball got through Turner and bounced to Bohm at third was a moment of levity on a night when the Phillies won and Turner drove in five runs, but in the big picture the defensive struggles at shortstop are no laughing matter and they’re not going to be funny when the games get bigger in September and October and a misplayed ground ball in the sixth inning of a playoff game costs the Phillies a series instead of just creating a temporary deficit that the offense can erase with a three-run homer the next half-inning.
Turner has 15 errors on the season with his third in the last four games, and the misplays that aren’t scored as errors but are ruled base hits on balls that a better defensive shortstop would have handled cleanly are just as damaging because they put runners on base and extend innings in ways that don’t show up in the error column but absolutely show up in the run column when those runners eventually score.
The Phillies entered Monday’s game ranked near the bottom of baseball in Outs Above Average and Turner’s defensive regression from last season’s improved numbers back to the error-prone version of himself from his first two years in Philadelphia is the primary reason the team defense has been a liability all season.
The front office has to at least be considering moving Turner to the outfield next season because the man has seven more years on his contract and the defensive issues at shortstop aren’t a slump that’s going to correct itself with better positioning or more reps at practice.
Trea Turner made 40 errors at shortstop in his first two seasons with the Phillies, improved significantly last year, and has regressed again this season at 33 years old, which is the age where defensive range and reaction time at the most demanding position on the diamond start declining for even the most athletic shortstops in the sport.
Don’t expect any changes in the short term because the Phillies aren’t moving Turner off shortstop in the middle of a pennant race, but the conversation about his long-term defensive home is happening inside the front office whether anyone wants to acknowledge it publicly or not.
Turner’s Bat Has Been Exactly What the Phillies Needed for a Month
The defensive issues are getting harder to tolerate but they’re also getting easier to stomach when Turner is producing the kind of offensive numbers he’s put up over the last month because the Phillies have been searching for a productive right-handed bat all season and Turner has become exactly that during a stretch where his bat has been one of the hottest in the National League.
Over his last 27 games Turner is hitting .324 with seven homers and 19 RBI on a .360 OBP that looks nothing like the .216 average and .268 OBP he was posting through mid-June when the bat was dead and the defense was bad and the whole package looked like a $300 million mistake that the franchise was going to be stuck with for the next eight years.
The adjustment to pulling the ball more consistently has completely transformed his offensive production and the Turner who hit two homers and drove in five against the Dodgers on Monday is the player the Phillies thought they were signing when they gave him the 11-year deal, minus the part where he can’t field a ground ball without the entire stadium holding its breath.
Monday night was the Trea Turner experience distilled into its purest form. Five RBI and three errors in the same game. Booed in the sixth for the defense. Cheered in the sixth for the homer. Laughing at himself in the ninth because the man knows his defense has become a comedy of errors and the only thing keeping the crowd from turning on him completely is the fact that his bat keeps producing enough to paper over the damage his glove creates.
The 200th homer of his career and the 300th double in the same game against the best team in the National League is a milestone night that Turner should be proud of regardless of what happened at shortstop. The five RBI gave the Phillies enough cushion to survive a game where the defense tried to give it back and the offense kept answering every time Turner’s glove created a problem that his bat had to solve.
The Phillies Beat the Dodgers and That’s What Matters
The Phillies beat Los Angeles 10-7 on Monday to open the series against the best team in the National League with the kind of chaotic, back-and-forth, offense-driven victory that has defined the Mattingly era since the day he took over.
The Phillies led 4-0 early, watched the Dodgers claw back to 4-3 partially through Turner’s defensive mistakes, and then responded with a four-run sixth inning capped by Turner’s three-run homer that blew the game back open and gave the pitching staff enough of a cushion to survive the late innings without the game becoming a coin flip.
Sanchez gets the ball Tuesday for game two against the Dodgers and the Phillies have a chance to take the series from the best team in baseball at Citizens Bank Park, which would be the kind of statement win that announces to the rest of the National League that the Phillies belong in the October conversation alongside LA rather than a tier below them.
The Dodgers at 61-36 are the standard in the NL right now and competing with them on a nightly basis at home is the test that the Phillies needed to prove the second-half roster is capable of matching up with elite competition.
Turner drove in five against the Dodgers while making the crowd’s emotions go from fury to ecstasy to laughter in the span of nine innings. The defense is a problem. The bat is a weapon.
The Phillies are going to need both parts of Turner’s game to figure out a way to coexist for the next 62 games because you can’t bench a guy who is hitting .324 over his last 27 games with seven homers and you can’t keep running a shortstop out there who has 15 errors and counting without eventually paying a price that the offense can’t cover.
For now the bat is carrying the glove and the Phillies are winning despite the defense because the offense is producing at a level that makes Turner’s errors survivable rather than fatal. How long that balance holds depends on whether the errors keep coming and whether the offense keeps answering, and Monday night was the most dramatic example yet of a player whose bat and glove are at war with each other every single night he takes the field.
The Phillies won 10-7. Turner hit two homers and made three errors. Citizens Bank Park booed him and cheered him in the same inning. He laughed at himself in the ninth because what else are you supposed to do when you’re simultaneously the best and worst player in the game.
That’s Trea Turner in 2026. You take the whole package or you take none of it, and right now the package is winning baseball games even if it’s giving everyone in the building a heart attack along the way.
Join The Chase
Read More
There’s only one Phillies fan that deserved the home run ball and it’s the guy in the Eagles jersey
Two Phillies fans are going crazy viral Tuesday morning over…
Phillies drop throwback uniforms for the Field of Dreams game
The Phillies released the uniforms they’ll be wearing for the…
Phillies lose 6-1 to the Mets as the fifth starter problem continues to get worse
Alan Rangel got shelled for five runs in four innings…
Comments (0)