Phillies depth called into question after 10-4 loss to the Nationals in extras
Five days after Andrew Painter gave them one of his best starts of the year in Baltimore, and literally hours after Mattingly went out of his way to say he trusted the kid in the rotation, Painter left Wednesday night’s start against the Nationals grabbing his left hamstring. You could not have written a more perfect “I told you so” if you tried, and it turned a bizarre night into a genuinely miserable 10-4 loss in extras.
This is the exact nightmare I’ve been screaming about all week.
The Phillies looked at a rotation with no depth, decided to do nothing about it at the deadline, and bet the season on Painter’s development and the health of their arms. Five days later, Painter’s hamstring is barking. No net under the tightrope, and they’re already stumbling on it.
Unbelievable, and yet completely predictable.
For four innings, Painter was doing exactly what the Phillies needed him to do. One run allowed, a nine-pitch fourth inning, and the reset that got him back to the bigs clearly still working. He got ahead of 11 of 17 hitters and kept pairing the improved fastball with the new circle-change. He punched out Daylen Lile with a four-seamer and blew a heater by CJ Abrams for a strikeout. It was legitimately encouraging stuff.
Then, 63 pitches in, done. Painter said he first felt the hamstring in the FIRST inning when he slipped after the Lile strikeout and just gutted it out, with the Phillies checking on him each inning before finally pulling the plug. On a humid night where he was constantly asking for new balls and hitting the rosin bag, the whole thing came apart.
The one sliver of good news is that Painter sounded genuinely optimistic afterward, saying the hamstring felt better once he came out and that he thinks he can still make his next start. He gets re-evaluated Thursday. Fingers crossed, because if it’s anything serious, this rotation is in real trouble, and everyone knows it.
Painter looked like he was actually turning the corner.
That four-seamer, which he’s been throwing less, is the pitch that unlocks everything, and he thinks ditching the splitter and its pre-pitch grip for the circle-change has helped him hold the heater more consistently and get more ride on it. In the second, he started Abrams with three sweepers and a change before going upstairs with the fastball for the whiff. That’s a kid pitching with a plan, not just chucking it. And then a hamstring interrupts the exact progress this whole gamble depends on. Brutal.
There Really Is No Phillies Backup Plan
If Painter misses time, buckle up, because the alternatives are grim. It’s back to the opener format with the reworked bullpen and Triple-A’s Brian Keller, OR the Phillies finally do what they should’ve done Monday and look outside the building.
Around now, teams start dumping struggling veterans with money left on the deal, and two beauties already surfaced: San Diego’s German Marquez and his 5.26 ERA, and Washington’s Zack Littell at 4.97.
Be still my heart.
That’s what standing pat at the deadline gets you. Scrounging the DFA scrap heap for guys with ERAs pushing 5.00 because your rookie fifth starter tweaked a hamstring five days in. This is the bed Dombrowski made, and now the whole team has to sleep in it.
Arraez Is a Menace and I Love Him
The one genuine bright spot, like every night since he arrived, was Luis Arraez. He led off the second by pulling a solo shot off the right-field foul pole and sent the crowd into a frenzy. The man brings juice to every single at-bat, and Crawford tacked on a bases-loaded sac fly to build an early lead.
Then, naturally, the offense flatlined. Jake Irvin, a guy the Phillies usually hit, retired 11 straight at one point. Same feast-or-famine lineup that can’t string anything together, deadline additions or not.
A Wild, Injury-Soaked Loss in Extras
The Phillies clawed back. Stott laced a game-tying single on a 3-2 pitch in the seventh, and Duran wriggled out of a two-on jam in the ninth to keep them alive.
They went quiet in the bottom half, and off to extras they went with a bullpen running on fumes. Alvarado walked the bases loaded in the 10th to give Washington the lead, salvaging some dignity by limiting it to one.
In the bottom half, Derek Hill swiped third as the ghost runner during a Schwarber battle, setting up Turner’s game-tying sac fly, which Dylan Crews robbed with a diving, full-extension grab that saved the game for the Nats.
Then Harper walked, got thrown out trying to steal second, and stayed down holding his wrist, though he gutted it out and stayed in.
And the injuries just kept coming. In the 11th, Abrams tripled off the center-field wall and Hill smashed his head into the fenced part making the play, staying down for over two minutes while the medical staff rushed out.
Derek Hill!!
He eventually walked off on his own with what Mattingly called a shoulder contusion, still being evaluated. Then Caleb Kilian got shelled for four more to blow it open, and a strange night turned into a soul-sucking one.
More Bodies, More Questions, Same Old Concerns
So here’s where we are.
Painter’s hamstring is a question mark that goes straight to the heart of the rotation gamble. Derek Hill, one of the best stories of the entire season, took a scary shot to the head and has a banged-up shoulder. Harper tweaked his wrist on a stolen base attempt. And the bullpen, new arms and all, couldn’t hold up when it mattered.
Mattingly says the loss won’t linger, and sure, it’s early August against the Nationals, one game doesn’t sink a season.
The bigger picture is exactly what a lot of us feared out loud. This team has no rotation depth, and the SECOND the fifth starter grabbed something, the cracks started showing all over the place.
The Phillies get updates on Painter and Hill on Thursday, and those two might just decide how fast Dombrowski has to eat his words and get back on the phone.
The gamble’s already being tested, and Wednesday failed the test. Painter showed progress, then grabbed his leg. The offense scored early, then disappeared. The injuries piled up, the bullpen buckled, and the Phillies coughed up a game they had a dozen chances to win.
This is the tightrope with no net and Wednesday night, everybody got a real good look at just how far the drop is. Pray for good news Thursday, because this team can’t afford much more of this.
Join The Chase
Read More
LISTEN: Phillies auction winner delivers a flawless performance on the radio broadcast
A Phillies fan who won an auction for the chance…
WATCH: Umpire forced to stop the game after Trea Turner was hit with a green laser from the crowd
We’ve got a strange one. During Tuesday’s game, an umpire…
Luis Arraez is an absolute lunatic at the dish and it’s exactly what the Phillies have been missing
I already wrote about the Luis Arraez debut but his…
Team should have traded Lizardo when they could. Fraud good pitchers can go for a lot.