Phillies were on the wrong end of a pitching duel in 5-2 loss to the Braves on Friday night

The biggest series of the year opened with a thud. The Phillies dropped the first of four to the Braves 5-2 on Friday night at Citizens Bank Park, and it was the same old story that’s haunted this team for years: no clutch hitting, and a bullpen arm lighting the game on fire at the worst possible moment.

Alec Bohm did just about everything he could, but the offense went ice cold when it mattered, and in shocking news to absolutely no one except Don Mattingly, Orion Kerkering delivered the backbreaker.

Let’s get into it, because I’ve got things to say.

Sanchez vs Sale

Friday’s task was taking down the ever-dominant Chris Sale, and it was always going to be tough. Sale walked in with a 2.06 ERA coming off a complete-game shutout, and he’d already handled the Phillies twice this season, holding them to one run over 13 innings.

The lone bright spot was Alec Bohm, who continued his excellent stretch by attacking early. He lined an RBI double in the second and crushed his 15th homer two innings later, both on the first pitch.

Phillies only had Alec Bohm at the dish

Bohmer brings one home pic.twitter.com/NXrA2CzqvR

— Philadelphia Phillies (@Phillies) September 4, 2026

A Rav4th Inning Bohment brings us within one@Toyota x #RingTheBell pic.twitter.com/7QSTrVCgvE

— Philadelphia Phillies (@Phillies) September 4, 2026

That’s the blueprint against Sale, because waiting around for the perfect pitch against him is where hitters go to die. Bohm saw something he could handle and pounced.

Unfortunately, nobody else did and that’s the whole game in a nutshell.

The Phillies went hitless in six at-bats with runners in scoring position against Sale. Six chances, zero hits. The killer came with the Phillies down 3-2, when Arraez led off with a double and Bohm had a chance to move the tying run, but Sale got him to roll a grounder to the left side and Arraez never budged.

Sale escaped, finished six innings on 102 pitches, and gave up nothing but Bohm’s two runs. When you can’t cash in with runners in scoring position against an ace, you lose. Simple as that and it’s something Phillies fans know all too well.

Cristopher Sanchez

Sanchez, tied for the MLB lead with 16 wins, kept the Phillies right in it despite not having his best stuff. He walked three and clearly wasn’t sharp, but he gutted out six innings on 108 pitches and surrendered all three runs in a single frame, the second, then slammed the door the rest of the way.

That second inning was death by a thousand cuts. Leadoff walk to Lane Thomas, first-pitch single from Dubon, and then Sanchez actually made good pitches, striking out the red-hot Sean Murphy on a changeup and getting ahead of Austin Riley.

He dotted another changeup on the outside corner, but Riley just threw his hands at it and poked an RBI single through the right side.

Ha-Seong Kim brought one home on a groundout, and Acuna laced his second hit to make it 3-0. The Braves did the little things right for one inning, and against two aces, that was the difference.

So yeah, Sanchez did his job but yet again, the offense didn’t do theirs.

Let’s Talk About Orion Kerkering, Because I’m Done

I’ve been done. Since last year. With the score 3-2 in the eighth, Mattingly went to Orion Kerkering, who has been terrible all season.

I’ll say it again like I’ve said it before. The Phillies should have gotten rid of Kerkering after what happened against the Dodgers last October. Bringing him back was a massive mistake, and now, a week into September, the kid is flat-out unpitchable.

He walked a guy with one out, then hung a sweeper to Mauricio Dubon, who crushed it into the left-field seats for a two-run homer that put the game away and completely deflated the team.

Kerkering has an 8.44 ERA over his last 19 appearances. Read that as many times as you need to. Eight point four four. There is no world in which this guy can appear in a high-leverage spot for the rest of the year. None.

I’d genuinely go as far as calling up Gage Wood and DFA’ing Kerkering into oblivion, because I have officially had enough. Whatever’s going on with him isn’t getting fixed on the fly in a pennant race, and every time he trots out there in a close game, it’s a disaster waiting to happen.

I won’t name names

Let me address something preemptively, because I already know it’s coming. Miss me with the takes from “media members” on Twitter whining that “Phillies fans are treating this loss like doomsday.”

No. Stop. That’s not what this is.

What Phillies fans actually realize is that the cupcake schedule everyone was celebrating in August is over. We’re in September now, we’re playing the NL East-leading Braves, and the exact same issues that have bitten this team the last few years are back biting us right in the ass again. No timely hitting. A bullpen you can’t trust in October. Scoring two runs over the last 18 innings.

This isn’t overreaction, it’s pattern recognition. We’ve seen this movie, and we know how it ends if it doesn’t get fixed.

Phillies MUST Bounce Back Saturday

The good news is it’s a four-game series, and one loss doesn’t sink anything. But the Phillies desperately need the bats to wake up, because two runs over 18 innings isn’t beating anybody, let alone the Braves. They get another lefty Saturday in Martin Perez, so the RISP struggles and the left-handed pitching will both be front and center again.

This is the biggest series of the year, and the Phillies just dropped round one in the most Phillies way possible. Time to answer back. Get the bats going, keep Kerkering as far from a close game as humanly possible, and even the series Saturday.

Kill or be killed.

Join The Chase