Phillies embarrassed in 12-2 loss to the Braves

The Phillies got their doors blown clean off in a 12-2 beatdown by the Braves on Saturday night, a game that came apart in about the ugliest way you can draw up. Short-handed staff, a nightmare fourth inning, a lifeless offense, and a position player pitching in the seventh. This was a bad, bad night, and it’s part of a pattern of this team rolling over and dying in Atlanta.

This started uphill. The Phillies scratched Jesus Luzardo, only the best pitcher in baseball since July, and were running a bullpen already gassed from an extra-inning loss the night before. So they went with Tim Mayza as an opener, and the man delivered, three scoreless innings and now a scoreless streak of seven straight outings.

Bryce Harper handed him an early lead with a first-inning solo bomb, then, in a moment I absolutely loved, took his sweet time trotting the bases, channeling his inner Acuna after all the garbage the Braves star pulled in our building last week.

For three innings, everything was rolling exactly to plan.

Phillies lead early thanks to Bryce Harper

Bryce go boooooooom pic.twitter.com/O2s0RKix17

— Philadelphia Phillies (@Phillies) September 12, 2026

The Phillies Fourth Inning Was an Absolute Catastrophe

Mayza walked off, and the whole thing detonated.

Where do I even begin? Mattingly went to Brooks Raley for the fourth, and Raley’s ugly Phillies stint kept getting uglier. He retired Baldwin, then coughed up a towering game-tying shot to Acuna. That’s the fourth homer Raley’s given up in just 14 appearances as a Phillie.

You know how many he allowed in 45 outings with the Mets before the deadline? TWO. Something is broken with this guy since he got here, and it’s turned into a genuine problem.

Then it completely spiraled. Raley walked Albies, gave up a single, and in came Grant Holman for his Phillies debut in an inning he’ll want scrubbed from existence. Hadn’t pitched in 13 days, surrendered two straight two-out hits including a two-run Dubon single, and then finally got the exact ground ball the Phillies needed from Sean Murphy.

Bryson Stott double-clutched at third and threw it low, Bohm couldn’t dig it, the ball skipped away, and another run scored. Stott’s first error at third, and it blew the doors off. Kim walked, a run scored on a wild pitch, Baldwin doubled home two, and Acuna, batting for the second time in the same inning, tacked on an RBI single. When the smoke finally cleared, Atlanta hung seven in the fourth and led 8-1.

The cherry on top? Not a single run charged to Holman was earned. The whole avalanche started with the defensive gaffe.

Here’s the part that genuinely has me worried, and it’s way bigger than one bad inning. The Phillies looked completely lifeless the rest of the way, which has become a sickeningly familiar sight in Atlanta this year. Two at-bats with runners in scoring position all night. Meanwhile Tyler Mahle cruised through seven and gave up nothing but Harper’s solo shot.

This isn’t a one-off. The same offense that was RED-HOT in August, sitting at or near the top of baseball in basically every category, has completely fallen apart. Through the first chunk of September, the Phillies have the lowest OPS in the majors.

From best in the sport to dead last in a couple weeks. That’s a five-alarm fire with October staring us down, and it’s the exact same offensive vanishing act that’s gutted this team in past postseasons. The bats need to wake up, and there isn’t much time left.

If you needed one picture of how far gone this night was, here it is. Down 9-1, with Chase Shugart again being asked to eat innings he shouldn’t have to, Garrett Stubbs eventually trudged out to the mound.

A position player pitching. In the seventh inning.

That’s the first time a Phillies position player pitched in the seventh or earlier since Roman Quinn back in 2018. When your catcher’s on the bump in the seventh, the night is a full-blown catastrophe.

Red October?

The Phillies rolled into Atlanta with a real shot to chase down the Braves in the division. Instead they’ve dropped the first two and now sit six back with 13 to play, and to make it worse, they’ve slipped one game behind the Cubs for the top Wild Card spot. Ground lost in both races, and the division is realistically slipping away now.

Look, one blowout doesn’t torch a season, and the short-handed staff earns some slack. But the big picture stinks. Atlanta has flat-out owned this team all year long, the offense has gone from best in baseball to worst practically overnight, and the Phillies are letting a golden chance at the division dribble right through their hands.

Harper nailed it in refusing to pin it on one play, because the ugly truth is this team just hasn’t done enough lately. This is the stretch where you find out who you really are, and right now the Phillies aren’t answering the damn bell. Flush this embarrassment, wake the bats up, and go salvage the finale, because what we’re watching in Atlanta is nowhere near good enough.

Join The Chase