Eagles go Tanner McKee to Joe Milton in 48 hours: Nick Sirianni tries to explain the QB change

Nick Sirianni stood at the podium on Monday and said Tanner McKee was the guy and there would be no changes at the quarterback position. By Wednesday afternoon, Mike Garafolo and Adam Schefter had the Eagles going to Joe Milton, and just like that, the Eagles front office confirmed it a few hours later.

It took 48 hours for Nick Sirianni to get overruled on who would be under center for the Eagles against the New York Giants on Sunday. On Friday, Sirianni had to explain how that happened. He didn’t, really. He just talked around it for 10 minutes.

Nick Sirianni on Tanner McKee & Joe Milton

“Things are fluid”

Asked why he made the switch, Sirianni said McKee “played solid,” but that going with Milton was what the team needed right now to win this weekend.

Asked why he didn’t wait until the bye, when Milton would have had an extra week to prepare, he said it was what he felt was best “in this particular moment.”

Asked what changed since Monday, he said he went back through the film and the game plan, and that “things are fluid.”

Notice what he kept doing. Every chance he got, Sirianni defended McKee. He played solid. He did a lot of good things. This is tough on Tanner. Coaches who decide on their own to bench a quarterback don’t spend the whole press conference vouching for the guy they just benched. They talk about what the new guy gives them.

Eagles players knew before the media did, right?

McKee said he was told on Tuesday. Sirianni had a press availability on Wednesday and said nothing. The first people to hint at the change were the players, who had no idea what they were allowed to say.

Sirianni’s answer was that he wanted to keep it quiet as long as possible so the Giants would have less time to prepare. He said his job is to protect the team, not to tell reporters and fans what they want to hear.

On its own, that’s a defensible answer. Coaches play games with the depth chart all the time but it would carry a lot more weight if the news had come from the Eagles instead of leaking to two national insiders before the head coach could say a word.

Obviously, this doesn’t look like a Nick Sirianni decision.

When asked who was involved, Sirianni said he makes the final call, then named Howie Roseman first among the people he talks it through with. You don’t need to read too far between the lines here.

A coach who says “he’s our guy” on Monday doesn’t wake up Tuesday with a new plan unless somebody above him had one. Sirianni looked beaten down at the podium on Friday, like a man answering for a call he didn’t make and defending a quarterback he wanted to keep playing.

This is nothing new. Sirianni has been tagged as the front office’s guy for years, a head coach who handles the locker room while Howie and Jeffrey Lurie steer the ship. Fair or not, moments like this are why that reputation won’t go away.

And that’s a real problem for a franchise that’s 2-5 and losing every week. If the head coach doesn’t control who plays quarterback, what exactly does he control?

I’m ready for Joe Milton

Whoever made this decision got it right.

McKee is who he is. He’s a steady, careful backup who can manage a game. He also hasn’t stopped a five-game losing streak, and “solid” doesn’t win you anything at 2-5. His best moment of the year was a long third-quarter touchdown drive against Dallas, and the Eagles still lost by 17.

Milton is the opposite. He’s raw, and he’s going to make some ugly mistakes. But he’s got one of the biggest arms in the league, he can make throws McKee can’t even attempt, and he flashed real talent in his one start with the Patriots back in 2024’s season finale. When your season is on the edge, you find out what you have.

So start Milton. Let him sling it against the Giants. At the very least, it’ll be more fun to watch than another week of checkdowns. Just don’t pretend this was Nick’s idea.

Join The Chase