WATCH: Chicago Cubs Catcher Carson Kelly hits for the most unexpected cycle in Major League Baseball history

There are baseball moments you see coming from a mile away — and then there’s this. On Monday night, Carson Kelly pulled off one of the most unlikely and honestly, unexpected feats in Major League Baseball history by hitting for the cycle in the Chicago Cubs 18-3 route of the Oakland Las Vegas Sacramento Athletics.

The Cubs catcher, hitting ninth in the order and coming in as a career .224 hitter with two triples in 558 career games, casually checked off every leg of the cycle in Chicago’s win and you really couldn’t even script it if you tried.

Carson Kelly notches his first home run as a Chicago Cub

Carson Kelly notches his first home run as a Chicago Cub 💪 pic.twitter.com/Az1qi64dBW

— Marquee Sports Network (@WatchMarquee) April 1, 2025

Carson Kelly hits for the most unexpected cycle in Major League Baseball history

• 1st PA: Walk. Okay, solid start.
• 2nd PA: Home run. First as a Cub, and the first real shock of the night.
• 3rd PA: Two-RBI single up the gut. The A’s had officially been put on notice.
• 4th PA: Double. Now the cycle watch is very real.
• 5th PA: Another walk, because why not rack up some OBP while you’re at it?
• 6th PA: Triple — yes, TRIPLE — to deep right-center, over JJ Bleday’s head. Kelly legged it out like his entire career depended on it.

Carson Cycle Kelly. pic.twitter.com/NWJMNJeWUj

— Chicago Cubs (@Cubs) April 1, 2025

And with that, a 30-year-old catcher who’s built more for blocking pitches than legging out three-baggers just made Cubs history. It was the first cycle by a Cub since Mark Grace way back in 1993.

Carson Kelly completes the 1st Cubs cycle since 1993!

Carson Kelly completes the 1st Cubs cycle since 1993! ⚾️🔥pic.twitter.com/xXMY1qs3wE

— Prospect Dugout (@prospectdugout) April 1, 2025

Carson Kelly’s final stat line was elite. He went 4-for-4, 5 RBIs, 2 walks, and a permanent spot in Cubs trivia nights for the next two decades.

It’s the kind of performance that makes baseball the most unpredictable sport in the world. Carson Kelly, a guy with 54 career homers and fewer triples than some relievers, just did something only a handful of players ever will.

Not to pile on the Boston Red Sox but Rafael Devers is out here looking like he’s swinging a blindfolded wiffle bat. The Red Sox DH who is supposed to be a franchise cornerstone has somehow racked up 15 strikeouts in 19 at-bats — more than Kelly had total bases on Monday. It’s a cold reminder that sometimes, the guy you least expect to go off is the one who delivers the knockout.

Carson Kelly might not hit for another cycle in his life. Honestly, he might not hit another triple this season. But on March 31, 2025, Kelly was the best hitter on the planet — and the headlines on April 1st make it look like an April Fools joke.

Join The Chase