Philly is the only city in HISTORY to have their NHL team lose, NFL team lose and MLB team lose in the playoffs and be eliminated all on the same day

Hello, Philly. October 9, 2025. Mark it down. Burn it into your brain. This was the night every sports team in the city decided to join hands and march straight into hell together.

Never Forget October 9, 2025

We always knew it was possible. Phillies in a do-or-die against the Dodgers at 6:08. Flyers opening the season against the reigning champs at 7. Eagles in prime time at 8:15 trying to prove they weren’t broken after Denver.

Three Philly teams, one night, all overlapping. The dream scenario was a sweep of greatness. Instead, we got a sweep of misery and unfortunately, it’s now in the history books.

Philly is the only city in HISTORY to have their NHL team lose, NFL team lose and MLB team lose in the playoffs and be eliminated all on the same day

The Massive Highs and Crushing Lows of Philly Sports

Cities in history to have their NHL team lose, NFL team lose & MLB team lose in the playoffs & be eliminated all on the same day:

Philadelphia – Today
Philadelphia – 10/16/1983

That’s it. pic.twitter.com/6dPYMGYN4g

— Greg Harvey (@BetweenTheNums) October 10, 2025

Three games. Three losses. All by the same damn score: 2-1. Nobody in pro sports has ever done that before. Leave it to Philadelphia.

The Flyers…

Let’s be honest, nobody really cared about the Flyers game to begin with. I’m pretty sure my guys over at The Liberty Yell are the only ones who tuned in. They lost to Florida, 2-1, and it was probably the best thing that happened all night.

More Pain: Flyers drop season opener to Panthers 2-1

The Phillies: Season Ends in Embarrassing History

The Phillies’ collapse deserves its own hall of shame wing. For the first time in MLB postseason history, a team lost on a walk-off error. Orion Kerkering threw the ball away and the season went with it. Spare me the “he’s just a kid” takes. He’s a professional athlete. He screwed up. He deserves blame.

Bryce Harper, Trea Turner, Kyle Schwarber — all of them shrank in the biggest moments. Harper especially. After building his October legacy in 2022, he just torched it in 2025. The Phillies’ stars had four games to deliver and didn’t. Rob Thomson putting Kerkering in that spot was a managerial crime, but outside of the starting pitching and Harrison Bader, everybody should be embarrassed.

Phillies Fans: Trea Turner, Bryce Harper, and Kyle Schwarber went 1-for-14 in an elimination game

The Eagles: Broken Team, Broken Locker Room

And then there’s the Eagles. What a disaster. The Giants hadn’t won a division game in years, and a rookie quarterback named Jaxson Dart shows up and turns them into world-beaters. He picked the Eagles apart like it was a 7-on-7 drill. Anytime he wanted eight yards, he had it. Wide open receivers everywhere.

The offensive line is a shell of itself. Saquon Barkley is getting crushed behind the line every other play. And the “big three” of Jalen Hurts, A.J. Brown, and offensive coordinator Kevin Patullo? Completely dysfunctional.

Hurts looks like a quarterback who can’t elevate anyone around him. Brown is throwing grenades inside the locker room while exposing that the meeting with Hurts and Saquon didn’t happen. And Patullo has turned one of the NFL’s most explosive offenses into the most predictable mess you’ve ever seen.

It’s a broken team. Broken foundation. While last year they were 3-2 and still ended up winning the Super Bowl, this year has shades of 2018 and 2023 all over again. The hangover is real.

Eagles get smacked by Jaxson Dart as Giants snap eight-game NFC East losing streak with 34-17 win on Thursday Night Football

Welcome to Hell, Philly

So yeah, the Flyers lost, the Phillies embarrassed themselves in historic fashion, and the Eagles looked like a rotting corpse on national TV. Three games, three losses, one city — and a night that perfectly explains why Philly fans are the way we are.

Whenever someone asks why this fanbase is insane, just point them to October 9, 2025. It’s all right there.

Join The Chase