Report: Eagles almost pulled off blockbuster trade for star QB in 2012 NFL Draft

2012 was a dark time for the Philadelphia Eagles. The Andy Reid era was coming to an end and the team was desperate to make the famed ‘Dream Team’ work. So much so that they were willing to mortgage their future for one of the best quarterback prospects of all time — Andrew Luck.

During the 2012 NFL Draft, the Eagles were among the teams that recognized Andrew Luck’s potential as he emerged from Stanford. Despite having extended Michael Vick’s contract for six years the previous season, the Eagles were still eager to acquire Luck. According to Zach Berman of PHLY, the Eagles made frantic efforts to trade up for the No. 1 overall pick, hoping the Colts would keep Peyton Manning and trade the pick away.

Ultimately, the Colts decided to draft Luck, leaving the Eagles to shift their focus. Philadelphia ended up selecting Nick Foles in the third round, a decision that would bear fruit when Foles led the team to a Super Bowl victory years later during his second tenure with the team.

Peyton Manning and the Eagles

During this period, Peyton Manning, who was being released by the Colts, also caught the Eagles’ attention. After Vick’s performance declined post-2010, the Eagles explored the possibility of bringing Manning to Philadelphia. However, Manning was not interested in joining a team that was in the same division as his brother Eli’s New York Giants.

This pursuit of both Manning and Luck illustrates the Eagles’ determined strategy to secure a top-tier quarterback — something that still persists to this day.

Andrew Luck’s tenure with the Colts, though shortened by injuries, was nothing short of spectacular. His unexpected retirement at 29 left a lasting impact on the league. Imagining a scenario where Luck could have been an Eagle adds an intriguing layer to his story and to NFL history.

On the other hand, Nick Foles, the Eagles’ third-round pick in 2012, became a key figure in the team’s history. Foles’ rise from a backup quarterback to Super Bowl MVP is one of the most remarkable stories in football. His performance in Super Bowl LII cemented his legacy in Philadelphia.

Years later, the quarterback destinies of the Colts and Eagles would cross paths again. In 2021, Philadelphia traded Carson Wentz to Indianapolis, linking the two franchises once more. Nick Foles, who had moved on from Philadelphia, also had a short stint with the Colts in 2022, further intertwining their quarterback histories.

The eventual successes of Nick Foles, the twists and turns of quarterback trades, and the persistent “what ifs” surrounding Andrew Luck’s potential path to Philadelphia offer a rich tapestry of narratives.

The intertwined fates of the Colts and Eagles quarterbacks serve as a testament to the league’s evolving landscape, where bold decisions and unexpected turns can lead to unforgettable moments. Whether it’s celebrating a Super Bowl hero or pondering the legacy of a retired star, the NFL remains a source of endless fascination.

Read More: Jalen Hurts taking ownership and working with Kellen Moore to improve the new offense