Shohei Ohtani seeking $325K in baseball cards from Ex-Interpreter Ippei Mizuhara and more bizarre updates on the infamous $17 million question

Shohei Ohtani is baseball’s crown jewel, a generational talent who just powered the Dodgers to a World Series title and pulled off MLB’s first-ever 50-50 season. But behind the MVP trophies and highlight reels, a far messier story continues to unfold—one that could tarnish the carefully polished image of Major League Baseball’s brightest star.

Backstory: Ippei Mizuhara, Ohtani’s long-time interpreter and confidant, is facing prison time after pleading guilty to defrauding Ohtani of $17 million. Mizuhara admitted to using the stolen funds to pay off gambling debts and now, splurging on high-end memorabilia, including $325,000 worth of baseball cards.

Shohei Ohtani wants the $325K in baseball cards back:

Ohtani has now requested a hearing from the U.S. District Court for the Central District of California in order to obtain ownership of $325,000 worth of sports cards purchased by his former interpreter Ippei Mizuhara, per Noah Furtado and Evan Drellich of The Athletic.

The U.S. Attorney’s Office for the Central District of California previously relayed in an April 11 statement that the 39-year-old Mizuhara previously stole over $16 million from Ohtani to cover gambling debts to an illegal California-based bookmaker. A portion of that money was used to purchased roughly 1,000 baseball cards on eBay and Whatnot.

“Mizuhara allegedly also telephoned the bank and falsely identified himself as Ohtani to trick bank employees into authorizing wire transfers from Ohtani’s bank account to associates of the illegal gambling operation.

“From January 2024 to March 2024, he also allegedly used this same account to purchase via eBay and Whatnot approximately 1,000 baseball cards – at a cost of approximately $325,000 – and had them mailed to Mizuhara under an alias, ‘Jay Min,’ and mailed to the clubhouse for Ohtani’s current MLB team.”

As The Athletic notes, “Ohtani wants those items back, arguing they were bought with his money.”

• Ultimate Fall Guy? Shohei Ohtani and his interpreter Ippei Mizuhara find themselves in a world of trouble with allegations of ‘massive theft’ and illegal sports betting
• Shohei Ohtani denies everything to do with Ippei Mizuhara and the investigation into him betting on sports, specifically Major League Baseball
• Shocker: Feds clear Shohei Ohtani of any wrongdoing, basically suggesting Major League Baseball’s biggest Cash Cow is the most oblivious man to ever live
• Just when you thought it couldn’t possibly get any more crazy, the 37-page criminal complaint against Shohei Ohtani’s interpreter Ippei Mizuhara has been released

Pretty weird, right? In my professional opinion, I think it would be best if everyone immediately pumped the brakes in assuming that Ippei Mizuhara was acting alone the entire time. It’s well within reason to believe that the “betrayal” narrative has been nothing more than a smokescreen the entire time.

Ippei Mizuhara: The Case of Shohei Ohtani’s Fall Guy

From the jump, the numbers in this case don’t add up.

How does someone wire $16 million out of your checking account over two years without you noticing? Ohtani claims he had no idea Mizuhara was dipping into his finances, but that’s a tough sell for someone as hyper-disciplined as Ohtani.

Maybe Mizuhara wasn’t just a rogue operator? What if he was the “fall guy” all along? It’s not unheard of for public figures to lean on trusted associates to handle their dirty work—gambling debts, bad investments, or unsavory activities—while keeping their hands clean.

When the heat comes down, the fall guy takes the blame, the star moves on, and everyone pretends it was just an unfortunate betrayal.

But what if that wasn’t the case and Mizuhara was more than an interpreter? Maybe he was deeply involved in Ohtani’s life and had access to every corner of his world? That kind of access doesn’t happen by accident, and it certainly doesn’t come without responsibility.

Could Mizuhara have been the frontman for something larger, willingly or not?

Deferred Contracts and Dodging the Spotlight

Let’s also consider Ohtani’s recent massive deal with the Dodgers. A significant portion of it is deferred—a decision that, on the surface, seems odd for someone at the height of their earning potential. But what if the deferment wasn’t just a financial strategy? What if it’s a way to keep too much liquid cash out of Ohtani’s hands amid whispers of gambling issues?

It’s not exactly unheard of for MLB to protect its marquee stars. The league has every incentive to preserve Ohtani’s pristine image. He’s not just a great player—he’s a global cash cow. Sweeping scandals under the rug, or at least keeping them contained, is a move as old as the sport itself.

Was Mizuhara All In?

Then there’s the possibility that Mizuhara wasn’t just a scapegoat but an accomplice. Mizuhara handles Ohtani’s gambling activities, gets a cut for his troubles, and everyone wins—until the money flow becomes unsustainable.

When it all falls apart, Mizuhara takes the fall as planned.

If Mizuhara was part of the operation from the start, it explains a lot. Why else would someone in such a precarious position splurge on baseball cards or dental bills? It feels too reckless to be random. Maybe he thought his role in Ohtani’s inner circle made him untouchable.

A Tarnished Legacy?

Ohtani’s dominance on the diamond is undeniable. But stories like this chip away at the squeaky-clean image that’s been sold to fans. If Mizuhara truly acted alone, it’s a shocking breach of trust. But if there’s more to the story—and let’s be honest, there probably is—it’s a glaring reminder that even the biggest stars aren’t immune to scandal.

Maybe Mizuhara got greedy. Maybe he was part of a larger scheme. Maybe Ohtani is exactly as innocent as he claims to be—or maybe he isn’t.

At the end of the day, it’s Mizuhara who’s facing the music. But this saga leaves plenty of unanswered questions, and the biggest one of all might be whether Ohtani’s innocence is as ironclad as we’ve been led to believe.

My Thoughts

I’ve been side-eyeing Ohtani’s role in this mess from the start. Mizuhara taking the fall feels way too convenient, especially when you factor in the timeline and the scale of the fraud. And the deferred contract with the Dodgers? That’s not just good bookkeeping—it’s a move that screams, “Let’s limit how much money Ohtani has at his fingertips right now.”

If Mizuhara was always the fall guy, it’s nasty business. MLB protecting its golden goose while letting a “friend” take the blame? Classic. But what really sticks with me is how poorly Mizuhara played this if he was in on the scam. Dude should’ve lined up his own fall guy to keep himself out of trouble. Rookie mistake.

If nothing else, this whole debacle has made Ohtani’s offseason far more interesting than it should be. Baseball’s golden boy might not be so golden after all.

Join The Chase