Jose Alvarado is looking extra beefy Clearwater, and the questions about last year aren’t going anywhere

Spring Training is open in Clearwater and the bullpen storylines are already flying around before anyone has thrown a meaningful pitch. Front and center is Jose Alvarado, who is back in camp, back in uniform, and back in the spotlight after a season that included electric stuff, an 80-game suspension, a late return, and the gut punch of being unavailable for October.

Let’s just say it plainly. Jose Alvarado does not look noticeably slimmer. If anything, he looks like he put the weight right back on after last year went sideways.

Jose Alvarado is back to being BEEFY

Jose Alvarado is back after being suspended last season and missing the playoffs pic.twitter.com/SqnIdqbVFM

— John Clark (@JClarkNBCS) February 11, 2026

Phillies Bullpen: Full Breakdown Heading Into 2026 Spring Training

Considering the suspension came under the league’s performance-enhancing drug policy, people are going to connect dots whether the organization wants them to or not. That is the reality of how this works.

Which makes it impossible not to remember the old Clearwater moment when Jose Alvarado laughed with reporters and said he felt like a fat boy.

It was funny because he said it himself and because relievers are wired in a completely different way than normal humans. Now the vibe is different. Now every camera angle turns into a discussion about conditioning, availability, and whether the Phillies are getting the dominant late-inning monster or the unpredictable adventure.

Jose Alvarado: “I’m fucking fat”

View this post on Instagram

Jose Alvarado says he feels “like a fat boy” in incredible Spring Training interview

Since 2024, Philadelphia Phillies relievers own a 4.06 ERA, which is fine, not special, not terrifying. The number is whatever. What actually matters is role clarity and who can end games without drama. The bullpen is supposed to be built on contrast. Different looks, different lanes, different ways to suffocate matchups in October.

Alvarado is supposed to be the loudest answer in that mix.

When he is right, hitters are cooked. The sinker has hovered around 99 mph and bullied barrels. The cutter comes out of the same window and vanishes. Opponents have lived under .200 against it for years. Before the suspension, he carried a 2.70 ERA and struck out 25 while walking four in 20 innings. That is elite, shutdown, give-me-the-ball stuff.

Then came the violation, the 80 games, the return with slightly less juice, the forearm issue, and the postseason ineligibility that left a crater in the bullpen plan.

José Alvarado is still the high octane, high chaos option.

Jose Alvarado slams the door to secure a @Phillies shutout! 🚪 pic.twitter.com/EVmAqYOEAr

— FOX Sports: MLB (@MLBONFOX) September 23, 2022

So yes, people are staring at him in February. They are allowed to. Trust was dented. Availability became a question. And when a guy reappears looking a lot like he did before the sudden mid-career body transformation, fans are going to wonder what version of the performance comes with it.

The Phillies exercised the $9 million option because you do not find arms like this at the grocery store. If he is right, he changes playoff series. If he is not, every late inning becomes a group therapy session.

That is where we are.

Camp optimism is great. Bullpens throwing in the Florida sun is great. But the only thing that will quiet the noise is Alvarado jogging in from the gate, pumping 100, and getting three outs without anyone holding their breath.

Until that happens, the questions are fair, and they are not going anywhere.

Join The Chase