I’ve been saying Mike Trout to Philly for years and now that the right side of the plate is a disaster, everyone is finally catching up

Bob Nightengale reported this week that the Phillies will be on the lookout for a right-handed hitter at the trade deadline. He also said Mike Trout will not be coming to Philadelphia because of his full no-trade clause and the $148.46 million still owed on his contract after this season.

I’ve been advocating for Mike Trout to Philadelphia for years. Years.

I have said it over and over on this site while getting trashed for it every single time. “It’ll never happen.” “The contract is too big.” “He’s loyal to the Angels.” “You’re delusional.” I heard all of it. From the comments to other media people. From my friends and from every single one of you random strangers on the internet who felt the need to tell me I was an idiot for even suggesting it.

Now everyone is talking about it.

Now 94.1 WIP is running segments on it. Now national reporters are specifically addressing the Trout-to-Philly rumors in their columns because enough people are finally on the same page that it has to be acknowledged.

The narrative gets hijacked every single time. I spend years pushing something on TLL, get laughed at, turn out to be right, and then the morons on sports talk radio act like they’re the ones who came up with it. The cycle never changes.

It was ALWAYS Mike Trout to Philadelphia.

Mike Trout joins 1,000 RBI Club and yet again, I’m asking Dave Dombrowski to complete a blockbuster trade at the deadline >>

The Philadelphia Phillies are yet again linked to Mike Trout as Major League Baseball prepares for the offseason >>

Mike Trout and the Phillies should already be calling the Angels to make a trade >>

No Brainer: ESPN’s David Schoenfield with a Phillies’ Mike Trout trade proposal that should be signed TODAY >>

The Right-Handed Hitting Problem Is Real

The Phillies’ right-handed hitters are slashing .217/.315/.585 this season. Dead last in Major League Baseball. For the dummies who are face-deep in stats, that’s a structural failure on one side of the plate.

The left side of the lineup is carrying the entire offense. Harper, Schwarber, and Marsh are all producing at elite levels from the left side. Schwarber leads the majors with 22 homers. Marsh is hitting .326, third best in baseball. Harper has been one of the best hitters in the sport all month.

From the right side? Adolis Garcia is hitting .203 and is exactly who we thought he was when he signed. The bounce-back year isn’t happening. JT Realmuto is getting older and his offensive production has declined.

Bohm has been much better since Mattingly’s two-day reset but he’s not a 30-homer power threat from the right side. Turner is fine as the leadoff hitter but he’s at .225 and isn’t providing the kind of firepower you need from a $300 million shortstop. You’re getting almost nothing from four or five right-handed bats while the three lefties feast.

The Phillies are 21-15 against right-handed starters and 4-13 against lefties. That split tells the whole story. When a lefty takes the mound, the right-handed hitters disappear and the lineup has no answers. Every team in the National League knows it. Every pitching coach has it circled. Start your lefty against the Phillies and you’ll probably win.

Why Mike Trout to Philly Still Makes Sense

I don’t care what Nightengale says about the no-trade clause. Mike Trout to the Phillies makes more sense than any other trade scenario on the board. Here’s why.

Mike Trout is from Millville, New Jersey. He grew up a Phillies fan. His family is in South Jersey. He has spent his entire career with the Angels, one of the most poorly run organizations in professional sports, and has zero postseason success to show for a career that puts him in the conversation as one of the greatest players in baseball history.

He’s hitting .241 with 14 homers and a .910 OPS this year. That’s a down year by Trout standards. That’s also better than every right-handed hitter currently on the Phillies roster.

Mike Trout is STILL the greatest baseball player EVER

That’s a very, VERY big fly 😱

Mike Trout nearly hit the roof with his 14th homer! pic.twitter.com/UFWpnfDj2d

— MLB (@MLB) May 30, 2026

The no-trade clause means Mike Trout has to agree to go anywhere. The $148 million remaining on his contract is massive but the Angels are going nowhere. They’ve been going nowhere for a decade.

Mike Trout has to look at his career and ask himself whether he wants to spend the final productive years of his prime losing 90 games a year in Anaheim or whether he wants to come home, play in front of his family and friends, and chase a World Series with a team that has the pitching to get there.

The Phillies have Wheeler and Sanchez pitching like Cy Young candidates. They have Schwarber and Harper in the middle of the lineup. They have a farm system with pieces to offer the Angels in a trade. They play in a ballpark 90 minutes from Trout’s hometown. The fit is perfect from a baseball standpoint and a personal standpoint.

The contract is the obstacle. The no-trade clause is the obstacle. But obstacles are overcome when both sides want the deal to happen. If Mike Trout decides he wants to come home, the no-trade clause is waived with a phone call.

If the Angels decide they want to move on from a $35 million annual commitment for a player in his mid-30s, the conversation starts. If Dave Dombrowski decides the right-handed bat he needs at the deadline is a generational talent from New Jersey who grew up rooting for the Phillies, the farm system has enough to make an offer.

The Realistic Names Are Fine but They’re Not Trout

Fans are throwing around names like Matt Vierling and Harrison Bader. I don’t need to revisit either of two former Phillies that don’t move the needle and are only considered fine additions for nostalgia and depth purposes. Sure, I guess Vierling can hit lefties and Bader can play center and run but what are we even doing here?

Neither of them changes the trajectory of a season the way Mike Trout does.

Adding a Vierling-type piece is a bandaid on a wound that needs surgery. The Phillies don’t just need a right-handed hitter who can platoon against lefties. They need a right-handed bat who fundamentally changes the lineup and forces opposing managers to think twice about starting a left-handed pitcher against them.

Mike Trout is that player. Even at 34 with a .910 OPS in a “down year,” he’s that player.

Dombrowski has a stocked farm system to work with. The Phillies have shown a willingness to make aggressive moves at the deadline in previous seasons.

The All-Star Game is at Citizens Bank Park in July. The World Cup is at the Linc. Philadelphia is the center of the sports universe this summer. Imagine Mike Trout being introduced as a Phillie at the All-Star Game in his hometown ballpark. The content writes itself. The marketing writes itself. The baseball case writes itself.

Make It Happen. Whatever it takes.

I’ve been saying Mike Trout to Philadelphia for years. The right-handed hitting numbers this season prove the need is real. The contract is big. The no-trade clause exists. The obstacles are significant. But the fit is perfect and the window for the Phillies to win a World Series with this pitching staff is right now.

Nightengale says it won’t happen. Maybe he’s right. But until the deadline passes and Trout is still wearing an Angels uniform, I’m going to keep pushing it because it makes too much sense for both sides. Trout gets to come home and chase a ring. The Phillies get the right-handed bat that fixes their biggest weakness. The Angels get prospects for a player they’re wasting.

Make the call, Dave. Bring Trout home.

Join The Chase